This book is written by oral historian, activist, filmmaker, heritage conservationist, trustee on SAHMAT,and author. He is also well known for his heritage walks in Delhi that explore the culture, food and architecture of Delhi.
In this book he tries to bust the myth of Islamic Architecture and establish that architecture is more geographical than religious. He challenges colonial narratives that domes and minarets were Islamic - a narrative that probably gave the colonial forces leverage.He says that domes and minarets were originally not part of early Islamic architecture and were influenced by Persian and Turkish cultures.
The books starts with the motif of kalash or the vessel to carry water which has been around since Harappan times, often also seen in cultures as a womb (garbha kalash) and how as a sign of fertility it is has been incorporated in the design of Indian architecture. He takes the example of the mosque of Qutbbuddin Aibak in Qutb Minar area which has motifs of kalash and nagas mostly taken from Jain temples and used in the mosque. The same motifs continue at the Alai Darwaza. Adham Khan's tomb, Khazanchi ki Haveli in Shahjehanabad.
Then he discusses the idea of lotuses as a motif, symbolising purity, used in Hindu and Buddhist structures. Lotuses are designed into the architecture of Firos Shah Tughluq's tomb, Humayun's tomb, Jamali Kamali mosque. This could be because the architect's were Persian but the masons and workers were local.
The Alai Darwaza is one of the oldest domes and the idea of a dome and the true arch as a load bearing structure were introduced by Turks or Afghans who also bought the idea of building with rubble masonry. The local workers began fitting lotuses on top of the domes as seen in Sheesh Mahal and Rang Mahal at Red Fort, Rajon ki baoli etc. he brings the motif of amalaka seen on temple shikharas (wheel with serrated edges) used in temples which has also found its way, as also the motif of a coconut which is also a sign of fertility. He examines motifs of the Swastika which was found in other cultures, the six edged star which is also found in other cultures.
As for arches he says that for years the true arch with a keystone was not trusted by the local masons and engineers to take the load and distribute it efficiently and therefore many structures show arches with lintels and other support structures like having a trabeated opening or corbels which made them like stepped arches. Masons would incorporate a form of Gajalakshmi into the corbels without the details of an elephant head etc.
Minarets as a means to call for prayer did not hold water and Sohail surmises that be it minarets, shikharas, steeples, the idea was probably to get closer to God and nothing else. No mosque before Jama Masjid (1656) had minarets and different structures existed for mosques in Kerala and in Kashmir in the olden times with no domes and minarets.
In his 117 page book Sohail makes a case that architecture is by and large geographical and shaped by climate, material and technology and not by religion. Domes existed in the times of Romans. Jews, Christians, Muslims and they are to provide an equal space and nothing more.
Interesting book and it has certainly given me a good insight into architecture. I bought this book when attending a talk of Sohail Hashmi at the Salar Jung Museum last week and he interestingly signed it - 'With Love'. Not many do that. Sohail is also the brother of Safdar Hashmi the playwright and director who staged street plays and was murdered in 1989 while staging a street play Halla Bol.

No comments:
Post a Comment